Sitemap

Book Review

The Post-pandemic Economic Overhaul Will Take More Than Tweaks

In Capital and Ideology (first published in 2019), Thomas Piketty documents the global rise of inequality and critiques ideas that legitimize it. He builds on his bestselling 2013 book Capital in the Twenty-First Century, which spurred a public debate on growing gaps between the haves and have-nots in Europe and the United States.

His latest work is important, especially because — before the pandemic —magazine The Economist had raised doubts about the extent to which inequality has really been rising. But in downplaying the roles of material interests, structures of production and capitalist dynamics, Piketty’s analysis is concerning.

His argument is that societies always try to justify their imbalances and that the prevailing justification rests on shaky foundations. He argues that differences in wages today are often justified by a “meritocratic fairy tale”, in which people believe that the entrepreneurial earn wealth and those living in poverty simply need to work harder. But, of course, Western societies are not meritocratic. As Piketty demonstrates, discrimination is common — based on status, race, gender and religion. In the COVID-19 pandemic, could our obvious dependence on undervalued work in sectors such as nursing, care of children and older people, grocery provision and delivery shift perception of the extent to which these workers deserve the low wages of their jobs, which are often precarious?

Piketty discusses what he sees as the success of the period of social democracy in Europe and the US in the 1950s to the 1970s when the gap between the richest and poorest was narrower. He notes that most people who voted for social-democratic parties between 1950 and 1980 were workers, but that the vote has since shifted to the educated and middle class. Uneducated workers have thereby largely been left behind, paving the way for phenomena such as the election of US President Donald Trump and the United Kingdom’s referendum on leaving the European Union.

Piketty does not recognize the political battle over ideas in academia, although this could help him to explain shifts since the 1970s, including economics departments squeezing out Keynesian and Marxist perspectives. Instead, Piketty simply draws a sharp line between knowledge production and politics. He labels his own empirical work “rational” and “unbiased”, but his policy recommendations “ideological”.

This is problematic. Economists’ perceptions of their own analyses as being free of ideology often hinder open and democratic debate. The behavioural-economics work suggesting that the United Kingdom should not enter lockdown, which might have guided the UK government at the beginning of its COVID‑19 response, is just one example. In that case, a particular way of seeing the economy — as composed of separate individuals responding rationally to incentives — was presented as an objective foundation for an evidence-based policy that legitimized delays in social distancing. Yet such evidence cannot be considered purely objective, and in this case, it contradicted World Health Organization recommendations.

Piketty makes sweeping statements: he sees ideologies as social constructs with lives of their own, independent of what stakeholders stand to gain or lose. For example, he argues that one of the stated justifications for colonialism was the colonizers’ idea of having a “civilizing mission”; this is true, but the prevailing motivation was, without doubt, the vast wealth to be acquired. Clarity here is essential for understanding the generation of massive global injustice. Similarly, Piketty does not provide convincing evidence that, as he claims, inequality in post-colonial countries such as South Africa is driven by ideas legitimizing chasms in opportunity, rather than, for example, the stubborn persistence of racist institutions.

It is ironic that Piketty nods frequently to Karl Marx while simultaneously ignoring key Marxist insights about dynamics such as the profit motive, unequal access to and ability to develop technology, and labour-squeezing cost-cutting. At times, it seems that Piketty simply equates capital with wealth, because he focuses both his analysis and his policy recommendations largely on wealth transfers. For example, rather than interrogating how we as society work, produce and consume, his solutions are biased towards redistribution without changing the core of the system.

This limits his capacity to explain global phenomena. This is clear in his view on the effects of trade liberalization: rather than exploring how the removal of barriers to imports in the 1980s led to a collapse of industry in the global south, Piketty focuses on the loss of income from tariffs. In the same vein, his proposals shy away from discussing the massive rebalancing of global finance and production that is necessary; instead, he focuses on aid transfers to governments and taxation.

His policy proposals don’t challenge our reliance on capitalist growth. Rather, they involve adjustments to the existing order, such as redistribution and the inclusion of employees on company boards. Therefore, the worry articulated in the United Kingdom’s most right-leaning quality newspaper, The Daily Telegraph, that Piketty is back “more dangerous than ever”, because of his vilification of entrepreneurs and billionaires, is in my view unfounded.
Despite its shortcomings, this book does have the potential to start an important debate about how to restructure society in a more egalitarian and ecologically sustainable way.

Related Articles

Overdue, Expensive And Ineffective

Instead of indiscriminately giving a hundred euros to every citizen, help should have been given - simply and without delay - to those who...

Olivér Várhelyi, European Commissioner for Neighbourhood and Enlargement

Boycott Is Not An Option

As we now seem to slowly emerge out of this crisis, it is more important than ever that all citizens and political actors have...

H.E. Andrea Orizio, Head of the OSCE Mission to Serbia

Monitoring Elections In A Time Of Covid-19

In the build-up to the elections to be held on 21st June, the OSCE's Head of Mission in Serbia, Ambassador Andrea Orizio, stresses that...

The Franco-German Proposal for a COVID-19 Recovery Fund

One Giant Leap For Europe?

The Franco-German proposal for a COVID-19 recovery fund is not quite the “Hamiltonian moment” that some have claimed. But, by reshaping the debate on...

Will Serbia feel the ramifications of the rupturing of global...

When Germany And China Sneeze…

The automotive sector in Serbia could become a litmus test for assessing whether the country will continue to be included in European production chains,...

Marko Čadež, President, CCIS

We Have Reason For Both Optimism And Caution

It is encouraging that half of the domestic companies are planning to continue investing in equipment and basic resources and that large foreign companies...

Igor Vijatov, Director of the Serbian Automotive Cluster

No Fleeing Of Automotive Industry Investors

Although the world automotive industry has been hit hard by Covid-19, we have no reason to believe that factories representing parts of large global...

Jovan Protić, National Coordinator for Serbia at the ILO

First Health, Then Production

The extent to which the Serbian economy will be hit by disruptions to supply chains will depend primarily on the speed of curbing the...

More...

Webinar On “Peacekeeping In The Francophone Space In The 21st Century”

Co-organized by Embassy of Egypt in Belgrade, Conflux Centre and the Cairo Center for Conflict Resolution and Peacekeeping Within the Month of Francophonie: Webinar...

The Pearl Of The Maghreb: Virtual Exhibition By The Art Photographer Vladimir Lukač

The Association of Friends of Algeria is now presenting a virtual exhibition of photographs named “Algeria - the Pearl of the Maghreb”, by the...

Želimir Žilnik, Film Director, Screenwriter And President Of The Martovski Festival Jury

I Don’t Skip “March”

Without the Martovski festival , for all these decades, the domestic film scene wouldn’t only have been poorer, but I’m convinced it wouldn’t even...

The Belgrade Documentary And Short Film Festival

Seven Unforgettable Days

Since its inception and to this day, the Martovski festival has represented an important platform for the promotion of domestic documentary films, short...

News

EU Delegation and Council of Europe Office Welcome New Rules Aimed at Preventing Undue Influence on Judges and Prosecutors

The Serbian High Judicial Council (HJC) and the State Prosecutorial Council (SPC) have adopted on 15 and 19 April 2021...

The European Commission And Austria Secure COVID-19 Vaccines For The Western Balkans

The European Commission and Austria are announcing today the conclusion of agreements for the delivery of COVID-19 vaccines for...

Greece Removes Quarantine For Travellers From EU And Other Countries

Greece has lifted its quarantine requirement for travellers from the European Union provided they have been vaccinated or tested...

WHO Describes Immunisation Process In Serbia As Impressive

Prime Minister Ana Brnabic talked with World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional Director for Europe Hans Kluge about the epidemiological...

Humanitarian Cash Transfers For Families With Children As Part Of The COVID-19 Recovery Response

Darija Kisic Tepavcevic, Minister of Labour, Employment, Veteran and Social Affairs, Anthony Godfrey, US Ambassador to the Republic of...

EU Delegation and Council of Europe Office Welcome New Rules Aimed at Preventing Undue Influence on Judges and Prosecutors

The Serbian High Judicial Council (HJC) and the State Prosecutorial Council (SPC) have adopted on 15 and 19 April 2021...

The European Commission And Austria Secure COVID-19 Vaccines For The Western Balkans

The European Commission and Austria are announcing today the conclusion of agreements for the delivery of COVID-19 vaccines for...

Greece Removes Quarantine For Travellers From EU And Other Countries

Greece has lifted its quarantine requirement for travellers from the European Union provided they have been vaccinated or tested...

WHO Describes Immunisation Process In Serbia As Impressive

Prime Minister Ana Brnabic talked with World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional Director for Europe Hans Kluge about the epidemiological...

Humanitarian Cash Transfers For Families With Children As Part Of The COVID-19 Recovery Response

Darija Kisic Tepavcevic, Minister of Labour, Employment, Veteran and Social Affairs, Anthony Godfrey, US Ambassador to the Republic of...

EU Delegation and Council of Europe Office Welcome New Rules Aimed at Preventing Undue Influence on Judges and Prosecutors

The Serbian High Judicial Council (HJC) and the State Prosecutorial Council (SPC) have adopted on 15 and 19 April 2021...

The European Commission And Austria Secure COVID-19 Vaccines For The Western Balkans

The European Commission and Austria are announcing today the conclusion of agreements for the delivery of COVID-19 vaccines for...

Greece Removes Quarantine For Travellers From EU And Other Countries

Greece has lifted its quarantine requirement for travellers from the European Union provided they have been vaccinated or tested...

WHO Describes Immunisation Process In Serbia As Impressive

Prime Minister Ana Brnabic talked with World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional Director for Europe Hans Kluge about the epidemiological...

Humanitarian Cash Transfers For Families With Children As Part Of The COVID-19 Recovery Response

Darija Kisic Tepavcevic, Minister of Labour, Employment, Veteran and Social Affairs, Anthony Godfrey, US Ambassador to the Republic of...