Sitemap

Sebastian Sosa, IMF Resident Representative In Belgrade

Government Must Maintain Good Work

Most of the previous economic programmes in Serbia succeeded in achieving short-term macroeconomic stabilisation, but failed to resolve the underlying weaknesses of the economy. I believe the authorities share our view that consolidating recent gains will require not only maintaining sound macro policies and strengthening institutions, but also fully completing the ambitious structural reform agenda

Serbia has done a great job on fiscal and macro stabilisation and enhanced its financial sector stability. Although structural reforms have been a mixed bag, considerable efforts have been exerted, and the government seems to be devoted to that job. Whether it will ask for a follow-up arrangement with the IMF following the conclusion of this one is up to the government to decide, “but the IMF stands ready to support future reform commitments,” says Sebastian Sosa, IMF Resident Representative in Belgrade, speaking in this interview for CorD.

Serbia’s three-year arrangement with the IMF is entering its final phase. How satisfied are you with what has so far been achieved?

– The results of Serbia’s economic programme supported by the IMF have exceeded all expectations in terms of macroeconomic stabilisation and growth. Fiscal consolidation efforts have been particularly strong. In 2014 the fiscal deficit had reached almost seven per cent of GDP, and public debt was on a dangerous path.

However, just two years later that deficit has narrowed to less than 1½ per cent of GDP—the lowest level since 2005—and public debt is coming down. And this sizeable fiscal adjustment has not hampered growth. On the contrary, it helped to boost confidence, supporting private investment and growth.

Notably, employment growth is also expanding, with over 160,000 private sector jobs being created in the last two years. On the financial sector front, the resilience of the system has improved, and the very high level of non-performing loans, which was affecting banks, is falling. All these achievements are great news and Serbia should be commended for them.

How seriously did the Government of Serbia take your advice that it is necessary to consolidate the progress achieved?

– Although progress in the last two years has been impressive, it is still too early to declare victory. We should consider that most of the previous economic programmes in Serbia succeeded in achieving short-term macroeconomic stabilisation, but failed to resolve the underlying weaknesses of the economy. These unresolved structural problems prevented growth being sustained, eventually bringing the economy back into recession, with rising unemployment and re-emerging fiscal imbalances.

I believe the authorities share our view that consolidating recent gains will require not only maintaining sound macro policies and strengthening institutions but also fully completing the ambitious structural reform agenda. And this is precisely what Serbia’s economic programme aims to do.

The government has so far been committed to these objectives and progress is visible in areas like improving the business environment, fighting the grey economy, restructuring state-owned enterprises, and reforming public administration. That said, in some areas more and faster reform efforts are needed to boost productivity and potential growth, and to ensure a faster convergence to income and living standards in European Union countries.

A key challenge now is to ensure that recent hard-won gains are consolidated and sustained over time, even in the absence of an IMF-supported programme

How is it that Serbia receives consistently good reviews from the IMF when the actual heart of the programme – the reform of public enterprises – has not particularly progressed?

– Let’s put this question in context. The programme was originally based on three pillars: fiscal and macro stabilisation, enhanced financial sector stability and structural reforms. Macroeconomic results have been excellent—especially in terms of fiscal consolidation—and the resilience of the financial system has been enhanced. 

Sebastian Sosa

Regarding reforms of public enterprises and SOEs, which were at the core of the reform agenda, it’s a “glass half full, half-empty” kind of scenario.

Of course, we would have liked to have seen faster improvement, but at the same time, few could have foreseen the progress made thus far, given the long history of unsuccessful restructuring and resolution efforts and the complexity of these reforms. Many steps have been taken to improve the performance of EPS, Srbijagas and Serbian railways, with the help of the World Bank and EBRD.

Petrohemija restructured its debt and signed a long-term agreement with suppliers, so it should not be a fiscal burden going forward. And about 390 SOEs—of a portfolio of 550—have been resolved since 2014, either through privatisation or bankruptcy. However, there is still a long way to go and now is the time for the government to reinvigorate reform efforts. It is critical to continue restructuring and investing in the modernisation of large public utilities to get them on a sustainable path. And important decisions are still needed to permanently resolve companies with long-term problems in the energy and mining sectors.

With this in mind, Finance Minister Dušan Vujović said that Serbia shouldn’t have to seek a new arrangement, but that one wouldn’t hurt. What do you think?

– Clearly, Serbia is now on a much stronger footing than two years ago. But we can never rule out risks of fiscal relaxation, which if materialised would have a negative impact on confidence and foreign investment. Therefore, a key challenge is to ensure that the recent hard-won gains are consolidated and sustained over time, even in the absence of an IMF-supported programme.

Strengthening fiscal institutions, including fiscal rules, and boosting potential growth by completing the reform agenda would help meet this challenge. It is of course up to the authorities to decide whether they want a follow-up arrangement, but the IMF stands ready to support future reform commitments.

The IMF has an almost universal image worldwide as a police officer, as an institution that forces countries into austerity measures without taking care of people and their lives, as is the case in Greece, for example. In contrast, the IMF has, for years been devoted to investigating inequality. Could you tell us more about that?

– The IMF has indeed been increasingly working on inequality, as well as social protection issues. Extensive research has been produced in the last decade or so in an effort to understand the causes, consequences and remedies of income inequality. One of the main findings is that excessive inequality poses risks to sustainable growth, while social protection is increasingly seen as a contributor to macroeconomic stability, as protecting vulnerable groups can help maintain social and political support for sustainable policies.

But inequality has been more than a research agenda for the IMF. The institution is undertaking concerted efforts to give more prominence to it as part of the practical work with member countries, for instance, by placing greater emphasis on supporting vulnerable groups in arrangements with low-income countries. In fact, 29 of the 30 most recent programmes have introduced minimum levels for social spending on priority areas like healthcare and education.

Many steps have been taken to improve the performances of public enterprises and SOEs. However, there is still a long way to go and now is the time for the government to reinvigorate reform efforts

Serbia is the country with the highest inequality in Europe. How much was this issue in your focus, given that high inequality also represents an aggravating factor for economic growth?

– Based on Eurostat data, Serbia exhibits higher income inequality than most countries in the EU, but the comparison of inequality across countries depends significantly on the indicator used. In any case, notwithstanding the need for fiscal adjustment under the programme, measures to minimise the social impact of some reforms were adopted with the help of the World Bank.

In our view, there is still scope for improving the targeting of social programmes, as many of them are poorly targeted, while those that are well-targeted, such as the Financial Social Assistance programme, are clearly underfunded. But I think it is also fair to say that, by restoring macroeconomic stability and avoiding an economic crisis, Serbia’s programme was effective in preventing higher inequality and poverty. It is during crisis periods that the largest increases in poverty and inequality are typically observed in emerging markets and developing countries.

Do these reductions in salaries and pensions, cuts in public administration, health and education represent the road to more or less inequality?

– Pension reductions and “across the board” cuts in public employment and wages were needed as the fiscal position was unsustainable. But now the priority should be targeted restructuring in areas like health and education, to rationalise staff numbers and skills, and a more efficient and equitable wage system.

Ultimately, the road to sustainable and inclusive growth entails completing the structural reform agenda. This is now the main objective of the programme, which is all about growing income in Serbia. And it appears to be working, as employment and private sector wages are growing, and to the extent that fiscal sustainability is cemented, public wages and pensions will also gradually be able to increase, as well as social spending in priority areas.

Going forward, the road to lower inequality will require stronger and more efficient pre-distributive policies—policies that improve access to good education and healthcare for all. But this is a difficult task that cannot be done overnight. So, in the short term, these policies should be complemented with the better redistribution, including by improving the targeting of social benefits towards the poor.

Related Articles

Belgrade to get new waste management facilities

EBRD contributes €72 million loan to joint investment as Serbian capital addresses a critical environmental issue • New landfill and energy-from-waste facility will replace unsanitary...

Kristalina Georgieva selected as new IMF Managing Director

The Executive Board of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) selected Kristalina Georgieva to serve as IMF Managing Director and Chair of the Executive Board...

Largest wind farm in Serbia Kovačica starts operations

Largest wind farm in Serbia yet starts operation Facility with 104 MW capacity to generate electricity for over 60,000 households EBRD supported the...

EBRD lends €160 million to UniCredit Bank Serbia

• €100 million EBRD loan for on-lending to small businesses in Serbia • EBRD loan includes €35 million local currency loan to boost local currency...

EBRD Serbia’s important partner in infrastructure projects

Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Construction, Transport and Infrastructure Zorana Mihajlovic met with European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) Director for the...

World Bank approves Serbia $40m loan for Trade and Transport Facilitation project

Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Construction, Transport and Infrastructure prof. Zorana Mihajlovic said that the Ministry, along with the completion of the construction...

EBRD supports energy efficiency investments in Šabac

Bank provides €2.5 million loan to upgrade residential buildings • EBRD boosts investments in energy efficiency in Serbia • Šabac to upgrade residential buildings • Project to...

36 inspections ready to work in eInspector software

The Ministry of Public Administration and Local Government, Office for IT and eGovernment and NALED organised the 26th session of the Coordination Commission for...

More...

Archbishop Luciano Suriani, Apostolic Nuncio In Serbia

Archbishop Luciano Suriani: History Calls Us To Overcome Divisions

If, on the one hand, we all remember the historic meeting of Patriarch Kirill of Moscow with Pope Francis in February 2016 in Cuba,...

H.E. Fedor Rosocha, Ambassador of Slovakia to Serbia

Ambassador Fedor Rosocha: Recognising Kosovo’s Independence Is No Condition For Serbia

Within Chapter 35 there are particular criteria that have to be fulfilled regarding the normalisation process with Priština, but recognition per se is not...

Vladimir Novaković, President Of The NALED Managing Board

Continuing Cooperation With The Government

The common denominator of the top three reforms that NALED will advocate for has crystallised more than ever during the Covid-19 crisis. Those are...

Sebastian Sosa, IMF Resident Representative in Serbia

Sound Fiscal Policy Remains A Priority

If the global crisis deepens, it will further impact Serbia through weaker external demand, the continued disruption of supply chains and tighter financing conditions....

News

Richard Grenell: Serbia-Kosovo Agreement Results From Trump’s Different Brand Of Diplomacy

President Aleksandar Vučić of Serbia and Prime Minister Avdullah Hoti of Kosovo took an enormous step toward a long-term...

Agreement On Normalisation Of Economic Relations Between Belgrade And Pristina Signed

President of Serbia Aleksandar Vucic and Prime Minister of the Provisional Institutions of Kosovo Avdullah Hoti signed an Agreement...

Symbols Of Belgrade Lit In Colors Of The Polish Flag

On the occasion of marking the 40th anniversary of the founding of the "Solidarity" movement, Branko's Bridge, the Bridge...

Montenegro Election: First Projections Point To A Tight Race

In Montenegro, the ruling DPS was nearly neck-and-neck with its main rivals, according to early and incomplete projections of...

Gorenje To Hire 600 Temp Workers Due To Surge In Orders

Slovenian home appliance manufacturer Gorenje is hiring some 600 temporary workers to cope with a record number of orders....

Agreement On Normalisation Of Economic Relations Between Belgrade And Pristina Signed

President of Serbia Aleksandar Vucic and Prime Minister of the Provisional Institutions of Kosovo Avdullah Hoti signed an Agreement...

Montenegro Election: First Projections Point To A Tight Race

In Montenegro, the ruling DPS was nearly neck-and-neck with its main rivals, according to early and incomplete projections of...

EU Awards One Million EUR In Grants For COVID Recovery In Tourism Sector

“#EUzaTebe – For Cultural Heritage and Tourism” project has awarded one million euros for 120 projects aimed at supporting...

UNDP And Embassy Of Slovakia Present Feasibility Study On Use Of Thermosolar Energy

The Mayor of Belgrade, Zoran Radojičić, met with the Ambassador of Slovakia to Serbia, H.E. Fedor Rosocha and Resident...

The EU Does Not Recognize Belarus Election Results

Members of the European Council held a video conference, at which they discussed the situation after the presidential elections...