Sitemap

German Elections By Karl Mathiesen and Zia Weise

Climate Is The Kingmaker In German Coalition-Building

The two parties crucial to forming a post-election government differ starkly on climate and energy policy

Climate policy is one of the keys to forming a new German government.

But with the two smaller parties crucial to forming a post-election majority coalition having utterly different philosophies on how to reach Germany’s climate goals, the issue will be a major faultline in upcoming talks.

The election of 25th September saw the Social Democratic Party (SPD) take a narrow win with 25.7 per cent over 24.1 per cent for the Christian Democrats (CDU/CSU). The Greens came third with 14.8 per cent, while the liberal Free Democrats (FDP), according to preliminary official figures, were fourth with 11.5 per cent.

Now the Greens and FDP are planning a common approach to bargain more effectively with the two bigger groupings.

It won’t be easy. The Greens have more in common with the SPD, while the FDP and the CDU/CSU overlap on many issues.

“The next government must be a climate government,” said the Greens’ coleader, Annalena Baerbock. She added her party wants “massive investment” in infrastructure aimed at greening and modernising the country, and favours a higher level of government intervention in the economy.

The FDP believes the free market will deliver climate goals. “The election result makes one thing clear,” Volker Wissing, the party’s General Secretary, told the broadcaster ARD on the morning after the election, “People don’t want climate protection at the expense of prosperity, and people also don’t want prosperity at the expense of nature and the environment. That’s why we need to bring these things together and work out a solution as to how we can reconcile climate protection and prosperity.”

Both the FDP and the Greens want the finance ministry in any coalition — currently occupied by SPD chancellor candidate Olaf Scholz. The Greens also want to create a climate ministry with the right to veto any other ministry’s decision to ensure all government policy is in line with the Paris Climate Agreement. The FDP has signalled it would be fine with a climate ministry, but without the veto rights.

The finance job will be “crucial for issues like public spending programmes, EU debt-and-budget questions and carbon pricing,” said Georg Zachmann, a senior fellow at the Brugel think tank. “That will be very important for moving from climate targets to actual climate policies.”

The climate affected the election through the catastrophic floods of July, but it wasn’t a clear factor in the election outcome. Almost half of voters polled beforehand said it was the most important issue for them, but fewer than a quarter actually based their vote on it.

The absence of a real debate over climate change highlights a broad consensus on the issue; every likely coalition member backs reaching carbon neutrality by between 2040 and 2050.

A battle over the future of the car sector shows the distance between the FDP and the Greens on Germany’s largest industry, and is a crucial factor in hitting the country’s upcoming climate targets. The European Commission has proposed 2035 as an end date for the sale of polluting vehicles, a date the Greens want to move forward to 2030

But the question of how to achieve that, an issue mostly too boring or complicated for stump speeches, divides Germany’s parties. POLES APART A battle over the future of the car sector shows the distance between the FDP and the Greens on Germany’s largest industry, and is a crucial factor in hitting the country’s upcoming climate targets. The European Commission has proposed 2035 as an end date for the sale of polluting vehicles, a date the Greens want to move forward to 2030. The FDP opposes any vehicle ban.

The Greens are critical of the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline from Russia, of which the FDP is also sceptical. But he election also saw the Social Democrats overwhelmingly reelected in the state of Mecklenburg-West Pomerania, where the pipeline makes landfall, and whose SPD leader has been supportive of the project.

Another critical divide is how to cushion households from the impact of climate policies.

The Christian Democrats and FDP favour pricing carbon emissions and relying on market mechanisms to spur companies to slash their products’ carbon footprint.

In a speech in the Bundestag earlier in September, Baerbock criticised the FDP and CDU for their free-market approach to climate and social policy. Relying on a high CO2 price alone “is deeply socially unjust,” she said. “The market won’t regulate the climate crisis, because the market does not care about people.”

The SPD also favours greater redistribution. But Baerbock repeatedly attacked Scholz for supporting Germany’s 2038 coal phaseout date even as he travelled to the flood-stricken areas in July. The Greens want to exit coal by 2030.

The division over carbon pricing could have major consequences for EU policy. The European Commission recently proposed extending its Emissions Trading System to cover fuels for road transport and heating — a system already in place in Germany, championed by the CDU in Brussels and supported by the FDP. But both the German Greens and SPD are wary of the idea.

Nevertheless, the reemergence of Social Democrats in Germany boosted the spirits – and potentially the political fortunes – of the EU’s Green Deal chief, Dutch Socialist Frans Timmermans, who tweeted: “Social justice, climate protection and the green transformation of our economy and society go hand in hand and the election result underscores this.”

“Ahead of the election, the parties liked to talk a lot about the climate,” said Ottmar Edenhofer, chief economist at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research. “If they mean it, they have to get serious now no matter what coalition. All parties are facing the same challenge … Whoever procrastinates now is driving up the costs and risks to all people.”

Related Articles

Cooperation Between Serbia, Germany In Field Of Climate Action

Prime Minister Ana Brnabic attended today the signing of the Joint Declaration of Intent regarding strategic cooperation in the field of climate action between...

Comment

Post-Merkel Cooperation

Some of the topics that top the bilateral agenda include strategic cooperation in the field of climate change, as well as in the field...

H.E. Thomas Schieb, Ambassador Of Germany To Serbia

Continuity Is A German Trademark

There is no doubt that the Western Balkans and EU enlargement will remain high on Germany’s agenda. Whoever becomes the next Chancellor will certainly...

Udo Eichlinger, President Of The German-Serbian Chamber Of Commerce

Cooperation Growing Wide And Deep

There are great opportunities for cooperation between German and Serbian companies, and both sides are ready to use those opportunities. German companies that currently...

Frank Aletter, Managing Director AHK Serbia

Growing Opportunities For Collaboration

Serbian companies are very well positioned to attract the interest of German investors seeking to diversify their supply chains or find alternative sourcing destinations....

Milomir Gligorijević, CEO Of Telegroup System

Knowledge Leaps Borders

TeleGroup system is one of the leading technology companies in the field of information and communication technologies, the modernisation of the electricity industry, technical...

Roman Strakoš, Managing Director, Brose Serbia

Ready For The Next Step In Serbia

Brose is the world’s fourth-largest family-owned automotive supplier. In 2021, the company’s new site in Pančevo started its operations - and the next development...

ZF Serbia

How The Vision Became Reality

The story of ZF Serbia began in 2018, when the foundations of this important greenfield site of ZF’s youngest and innovation-driving E mobility division...

More...

Cooperation Between Serbia, Germany In Field Of Climate Action

Prime Minister Ana Brnabic attended today the signing of the Joint Declaration of Intent regarding strategic cooperation in the field of climate action between...

Comment by Zoran Panović

Legacy And Disquiet

By calling on the presidents of Turkey, Serbia and Croatia – Messrs Erdoğan, Vučić and Milanović – Bosnian Serb leader Milorad Dodik (seemingly narrow-minded,...

Cvijetin Milivojević, Political Scientist

Freedom Is More Important Than Money

Alongside the concentration of economic levers of power in the hands of the Serbian progressive party, the propaganda occupation among the most influential media...

Danica Popović, Professor Of The Belgrade Faculty Of Economics

We Will Pay, Of Course

Media freedom is the first and most visible confirmation of whether or not democracy is functioning. Money is, of course, behind that, and it...

News

Enlargement Package 2021 Adopted By The European Commission

Today, the European Commission adopted its 2021 Enlargement Package, providing a detailed assessment of the state of play and...

Serbia To Hold 5G Spectrum Auction In First Half Of 2022

AmCham and Ministry of Trade, Tourism and Telecommunications work together to tackle illicit trade online The 5G network and associated...

Belgrade Security Forum Under The Motto “Testing Humanity”

The Belgrade Security Forum, the most important international foreign policy and security conference in the region, will take place...

Russia Suspends Its Mission To NATO

The Kremlin is also closing the alliance's liaison mission in Moscow. The announcement comes after NATO expelled eight members...

Serbian Government, Oracle Sign Memorandum Of Understanding

At the pavilion of the Republic of Serbia, at this year's World EXPO 2020 held in Dubai, a Memorandum...

Enlargement Package 2021 Adopted By The European Commission

Today, the European Commission adopted its 2021 Enlargement Package, providing a detailed assessment of the state of play and...

Serbia To Hold 5G Spectrum Auction In First Half Of 2022

AmCham and Ministry of Trade, Tourism and Telecommunications work together to tackle illicit trade online The 5G network and associated...

Belgrade Security Forum Under The Motto “Testing Humanity”

The Belgrade Security Forum, the most important international foreign policy and security conference in the region, will take place...

Russia Suspends Its Mission To NATO

The Kremlin is also closing the alliance's liaison mission in Moscow. The announcement comes after NATO expelled eight members...

Serbian Government, Oracle Sign Memorandum Of Understanding

At the pavilion of the Republic of Serbia, at this year's World EXPO 2020 held in Dubai, a Memorandum...

Enlargement Package 2021 Adopted By The European Commission

Today, the European Commission adopted its 2021 Enlargement Package, providing a detailed assessment of the state of play and...

Serbia To Hold 5G Spectrum Auction In First Half Of 2022

AmCham and Ministry of Trade, Tourism and Telecommunications work together to tackle illicit trade online The 5G network and associated...

Belgrade Security Forum Under The Motto “Testing Humanity”

The Belgrade Security Forum, the most important international foreign policy and security conference in the region, will take place...

Russia Suspends Its Mission To NATO

The Kremlin is also closing the alliance's liaison mission in Moscow. The announcement comes after NATO expelled eight members...

Serbian Government, Oracle Sign Memorandum Of Understanding

At the pavilion of the Republic of Serbia, at this year's World EXPO 2020 held in Dubai, a Memorandum...