Sitemap

More...

Violeta Jovanović, Executive Director Of NALED

Dialogue Is The Best Path To Successful Reform

What has enabled us to initiate major...

Slavica Savičić, State Secretary At The Ministry Of Finance

We Are Fully Committed To The Well-being Of Both Industry And The Public

I think we have managed to alleviate...

Mihailo Jovanović, Director Of The Office For IT And Egovernment

Serbia Has Positioned Itself As A Country Of Innovation

In the past three and a half...

Milan Pašić, Assistant Minister Of Education, Science And Technological Development

Magic In The Hands Of Teachers

Thanks to the dedication of teachers, it...

News

Europe Day Celebration

On the occasion of May 9, Europe Day, as every year for the last two decades, the Delegation of...

Prime Minister Edi Rama Wins Third Mandate In Albanian Elections

Albania’s ruling Socialist Party (SP), led by Prime Minister Edi Rama, has won Sunday’s election with 48% of the...

New Project To Support Innovation Driven Economy In Serbia

Serbia Innovates will create the first Serbian Supercluster to bolster country’s competitive advantages on international markets ICT Hub, as a...

Von der Leyen And Borrell Call For Rule Of Law Reforms In Serbia During Vučić’s Brussels Visit

President of European Commission Ursula von der Leyen and High Representative of the EU Josep Borrell called for positive...

Oscars 2021: Nomadland, Anthony Hopkins And Daniel Kaluuya Share Glory

Film drama Nomadland has scooped three Oscars including best picture, while British stars Sir Anthony Hopkins and Daniel Kaluuya...

Comment by Yanis Varoufakis

Europe is Unprepared for the COVID-19 Recession

If there is one European body that has consistently demonstrated its lack of fitness for managing economic crises, it is the Eurogroup of eurozone finance ministers. True to form, it will respond to the COVID-19 crisis with heroic announcements heralding impressive numbers that disguise the irrelevance and timidity of the agreed policies

The Eurogroup of eurozone finance ministers is struggling to agree on a macroeconomically significant coordinated fiscal response to the enormous recessionary effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. The result, I fear, will be heroic announcements heralding impressive numbers that disguise the irrelevance and timidity of the agreed policies.

The first indication of this comes from the recent announcement of the German government’s financial aid package to the private sector. While the international media referred to it as a €550 billion ($600 billion) bazooka, close inspection suggests it is no more than a water pistol.

Comprising tax deferments and large credit lines, the German package reveals a serious misunderstanding of the nature of the crisis. And it is the same misunderstanding that turbocharged the euro crisis a decade ago. Now, as then, companies and households are facing insolvency, not illiquidity. To arrest the crisis, governments must go “all in” with stupendous fiscal expansion. But that is exactly what the German package was meant to avoid.

Finance ministers from countries in deeper economic trouble than Germany (for example, Italy and Greece) will undoubtedly try to push for the necessary fiscal expansion. But they will hit the brick wall of opposition from the German finance minister and his loyal supporters within the Eurogroup. Soon the “southerners” will fold their tent, their acquiescence sealing yet another fiscally insignificant Eurogroup package that the oncoming recession will steamroll.

How can I be so sure? Because I’ve been there. I represented Greece at the Eurogroup meetings in 2015, where the defeat of our government’s desperate struggle to avoid more loans at the expense of deeper recession was decided. The methodical manner in which those Eurogroup meetings closed down any avenue to a rational debate on the appropriate fiscal policies holds the key to understanding why the Eurogroup will also fail to mount an effective fiscal defense against the pandemic induced shock.

Comprising tax deferments and large credit lines, the German package reveals a serious misunderstanding of the nature of the crisis. And it is the same misunderstanding that turbocharged the euro crisis a decade ago

One insight from those crucial Eurogroup meetings five years ago stands out: any finance minister from a struggling country who dares oppose the Berlin line, or to propose solutions that benefit the majority of Europeans rather than the financial sector, is in for a hard ride.

I came in for a very hard ride. Anyone listening to the long hours of the 2015 Eurogroup meetings, now freely available, will hear the President of the Eurogroup threatening to end the negotiations if I dared to table written proposals that Germany did not want discussed (only to brief the media later that I had arrived “empty-handed”).

Then there was the head of Europe’s bailout fund, the European Stability Mechanism, accusing me of caring too much about indebted households and too little about the (already bankrupt) banks’ capitalization. And let’s not forget Germany’s finance minister, Wolfgang Schäuble, demanding to keep for the German budget – “my budget,” as he put it – the European Central Bank’s profits from trading in Greek bonds. The EU had agreed that this money should be returned to Greece; in the end, Schäuble did in fact keep it for the German budget.

All the while, Northern European ministers wielded the threat of “Grexit” and, equivalently, Plan B (an alternative currency for Greece) to force me to accept more loans. Rather than offering realistic debt relief and restructuring, we were hit with a barrage of “take it or leave it” ultimatums, and a long list of calamities that would befall our people if we did not borrow more and accept ridiculous levels of additional austerity that guaranteed Greece would never be able to repay.

The 2015 Eurogroup meetings offer listeners a front-row seat on the blood sport that is unaccountable power. It’s all there: Crucial decisions flying in the face of science and simple mathematics. Bullying the weak until they surrender. Thinly disguised theft. Fake news weaponized against those who dare to resist. And last, but not least, contempt for transparency and the other checks and balances essential in any democracy.

It is no coincidence that these themes are now so prevalent across the West. The Eurogroup meetings of 2015 were, I dare to say, the field of European democracy’s defeat, which reverberated not just across Europe but also in the Americas and elsewhere. Within less than a year, Brexit and the election of Donald Trump were no longer amusing hypotheticals. The practices that the liberal establishment now decries were on vivid display in those Eurogroup meetings – the same institution that, today, is deciding on Europe’s fiscal policy response to the coronavirus recession.

We have a duty to enlighten citizens about how, even in our liberal democracies, decisions are routinely made in their name, against their interests, and without their knowledge by functionaries who loathe democracy even as they pretend to defend it

Euroskeptics, whether outside the European Union, like Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin, or inside, like Hungary’s Viktor Orbán, Italy’s Matteo Salvini, and France’s Marine Le Pen, will undoubtedly take heart from the release of the 2015 Eurogroup transcripts. But making them public is in the interests of Europeanism. Revealing to citizens the EU’s decision-making process, warts and all is a prerequisite for empowering democrats to save the EU by taking back control of our institutions.

Europeans are not stupid. Even if they do not know exactly what goes on behind closed doors in Europe’s decision-making bodies, they can sense that the resulting decisions fail to use existing resources in the interests of a majority of Europeans in a majority of member states.

We have a duty to enlighten citizens about how, even in our liberal democracies, decisions are routinely made in their name, against their interests, and without their knowledge by functionaries who loathe democracy even as they pretend to defend it.

If we fail, the EU’s decisions, especially during this pandemic, on fiscal policy, green investment, health, education, and migration policy are bound to be as ineffective as those that magnified the euro crisis ten years ago. Then, only the likes of Trump and Putin, and Europe’s own Orbáns, Salvinis, and Le Pens, who want to dissolve our common institutions from within, will benefit.

Yanis Varoufakis is the former finance minister of Greece, leader of the MeRA25 party and Professor of Economics at the University of Athens

Related Articles

Europe Day Celebration

On the occasion of May 9, Europe Day, as every year for the last two decades, the Delegation of the European Union to Serbia...

Yanis Varoufakis / Project Syndicate

Football Takes Capitalism Out Of Bounds

Last week, Europeans showed the red card to the moguls – and their financiers – who tried to form a Super League of the...

Von der Leyen And Borrell Call For Rule Of Law Reforms In Serbia During Vučić’s Brussels Visit

President of European Commission Ursula von der Leyen and High Representative of the EU Josep Borrell called for positive developments in the rule of...

The First Conference On The Air Protection Programme In Serbia

The first conference on preparing the Draft of the Air Protection Programme in the Republic of Serbia with accompanying Action plan was held. The programme is...

Distribution Of Laptops And Tablets, Bridging Digital Divide In Serbia For The Most Vulnerable Children Project

The Head of the European Union Delegation to Serbia, Ambassador Sem Fabrizi, UNICEF Representative in Serbia, Deyana Kostadinova, and Ivica Rakovic, State Secretary in...

Healthy Nature For A Healthy Life, The New Message From The Serbian Buses

The project “EU for Natura 2000 in Serbia” is launching today the campaign “Healthy nature for a healthy life” with the aim to increase...

Call for Written Contributions To The Serbia 2021 Annual Report

We would like to inform you that the Delegation of the European Union to the Republic of Serbia is starting preparations for the Serbia...

Twenty Ambulances Will Save Lives Across Serbia

Twenty health care institutions across Serbia received new ambulances with modern equipment today, thanks to European Union (EU) funds. These vehicles are part of a...