Sitemap

By Diane Coyle, Professor Of Public Policy At The University Of Cambridge / Project Syndicate

The Dangers Of Data-Based Certainty

Economists are rushing to embrace the use of big data in their research, while many policymakers think artificial intelligence offers scope for greater cost-effectiveness and better policy outcomes. But before we entrust more decisions to databased machine-learning and AI systems, we must be clear about the limitations of the data

Social media are full of claims and counterclaims about all manner of other data. Is global poverty declining or increasing? What is the real level of US unemployment? The scrutiny, sometimes leading to tetchy arguments, results from people’s desire to cite – or challenge – the authority of data to support their position or worldview.

Economists are rushing to embrace the use of big data in their research, while many policymakers think artificial intelligence offers scope for greater cost-effectiveness and better policy outcomes. But before we entrust more decisions to data-based machine-learning and AI systems, we must be clear about the limitations of the data.

Already, too little attention is paid to the uncertainties inherent in economic data. Although policymakers generally appreciate that even something as basic as GDP growth is subject to large uncertainties and revisions, it seems impossible to stop people from building narratives on weak foundations.

For example, cross-country comparisons of the pandemic’s impact on national GDP are fraught with difficulty, owing to differences in economic structure and statistical methodology. But that does not stop claims about which economies are weathering the crisis better or worse.

Or consider the “true” rate of inflation. Seemingly technical disputes about how best to construct a price index mask profound distributional conflicts, such as those between borrowers and bond holders, or workers and employers.

The data we use shape our view of a complex, changing world. But data represent reality from a particular perspective. Data of the kind deployed in policy debates are rarely completely unanchored from the world they describe, but the lens they provide can be sharp or blurry – and there is no escaping the perspective they offer.

One possible reason for the current distrust of economic “expertise” is the growing gap between top-down, technical economic assessments based on familiar data series, and an alternative world of more granular data presenting the bottom-up picture. Standard economic statistics capture average experience, which ceases to be typical when people’s fortunes diverge.

In general, advocates of evidence-based policy are aware of the inherent uncertainty of available data. Researchers take great care regarding sampling, the scope for error, and the limitations of the data-collection method used. But the degree of false certainty tends to increase with proximity to policy and political decision-making. Former US President Harry S. Truman is far from the only politician to have expressed impatience with economists who say, ‘On the one hand…,’ then, ‘but on the other.’

But the current hunger for data-based certainty is becoming dangerous as we increasingly rely on technocratic decision procedures – including machine-learning systems – for policymaking in areas such as criminal justice, policing, and welfare.

Democracies often rely on constructive ambiguity to reconcile conflicting interests, such as those regarding the distribution of returns to an asset, or to address the question of whether law-enforcement authorities should err on the side of imprisoning innocent people or letting criminals walk free. Claims to data-based authority minimize or eliminate the scope of ambiguity, with potentially significant consequences.

Related Articles

Javier Solana/Project Syndicate

European Integration In A Fragmenting World

The European Union’s undeniable success in advancing regional integration does not make it a finished project. As threats to global stability increase, the EU...

Jayati Ghosh/Project Syndicate

The Rich World’s Climate Hypocrisy

Many of the statements by developed-country leaders at the COP26 summit in Glasgow are at odds with their actual climate policies, and with what...

By Carl Bildt, Project Syndicate

The Dangerous Balkan Standstill

Even after a quarter-century of relative peace, the Balkans have yet to achieve the lasting stability that was hoped for when the region’s wars...

By Georg E. Riekeles / Project Syndicate

Switzerland’s Brexit Moment

Many in Switzerland have failed to recognise that their exorbitant privileges vis-à-vis the European Union could not continue. The Swiss government’s recent withdrawal from...

By Michael Spence / Project Syndicate

How Great Powers Should Compete

Both China and the West espouse some version of multilateralism. But unfettered strategic competition, together with relentlessly negative rhetoric, precludes effective multilateralism, not least...

Zoran Panović

German Imagination

If Serbia does not recognise the independence of Kosovo (even discreetly, through a “legally binding paper”) by the end of Angela Merkel’s term as...

Miloš Zeman, President Of The Czech Republic

Recognition Of Kosovo Is A Mistake

For my many years in politics, I am known as a person who is consistent in his opinions. I still consider the recognition of...

H.E. Silvia Davidoiu, Ambassador of Romania

Connecting Balkan Infrastructure And Energy

We are looking forward to the construction of the Trans-Balkan Power Corridor that will connect the electricity transmission systems of the entire region and...

More...

Comment by Zoran Panović

Nihilistic Tendencies

All gatherings of Western Balkan leaders under the patronage of Merkel-Macron turned assuredly into a routine of indecision, while the impression of futility has...

Bora Babić, Director And Editor-in-Chief Of Publishing House Akademska knjiga [Academic Book]

Between Courage And Fear

A good book always enlightens, and we might be wise to read them more often, even as a self-imposed assignment. It is only by...

Branko Kukić, Editor Of The Official Gazette

Literary Bazaars

Publishing books is a process that’s connected to knowledge, to creation, to goals that are important for the formation of any society. And that...

Gojko Božović, Poet And Editor-in-Chief Of Publishing House Arhipelag [Archipelago]

Digital Reality Brings Into Question The Book Fair Concept

Even prior to the pandemic, book fairs faced the question: what to do today and how to continue to exist under fundamentally altered social,...

News

Nobel Prize In Literature Awarded To French Author Annie Ernaux

The 2022 Nobel Prize in Literature is awarded to the French author Annie Ernaux for the courage and clinical...

Japanese Investments In Serbia Reached 200 Million Euros

Japanese investments in Serbia reached 200 million euros, of which more than half occurred in the past two years. The...

Saudi Arabia: Strengthening Cooperation With Serbia

The business community is a key factor in building good relations between countries, emphasized the Minister of Foreign Affairs...

Ambassador Chen Bo: China Will Always Contribute To The World Peace And Development

Respect for national sovereignty and territorial integrity is established as an important principle of the UN Charter and represents...

Reception On The Occasion Of The Day Of German Unity Held In Belgrade

On the occasion of the Day of German Unity, in the Botanical Garden in Belgrade, the Embassy of Germany...

Nobel Prize In Literature Awarded To French Author Annie Ernaux

The 2022 Nobel Prize in Literature is awarded to the French author Annie Ernaux for the courage and clinical...

Saudi Arabia: Strengthening Cooperation With Serbia

The business community is a key factor in building good relations between countries, emphasized the Minister of Foreign Affairs...

Ambassador Chen Bo: China Will Always Contribute To The World Peace And Development

Respect for national sovereignty and territorial integrity is established as an important principle of the UN Charter and represents...

Reception On The Occasion Of The Day Of German Unity Held In Belgrade

On the occasion of the Day of German Unity, in the Botanical Garden in Belgrade, the Embassy of Germany...

Response to War in Ukraine Key Focus Area For IFC’s New Regional Director For Europe

IFC has appointed Rana Karadsheh as Regional Director for Europe. Based in Vienna, she will play a key role...

Nobel Prize In Literature Awarded To French Author Annie Ernaux

The 2022 Nobel Prize in Literature is awarded to the French author Annie Ernaux for the courage and clinical...

Saudi Arabia: Strengthening Cooperation With Serbia

The business community is a key factor in building good relations between countries, emphasized the Minister of Foreign Affairs...

Ambassador Chen Bo: China Will Always Contribute To The World Peace And Development

Respect for national sovereignty and territorial integrity is established as an important principle of the UN Charter and represents...

Reception On The Occasion Of The Day Of German Unity Held In Belgrade

On the occasion of the Day of German Unity, in the Botanical Garden in Belgrade, the Embassy of Germany...

Response to War in Ukraine Key Focus Area For IFC’s New Regional Director For Europe

IFC has appointed Rana Karadsheh as Regional Director for Europe. Based in Vienna, she will play a key role...