Sitemap

Economists vs. Scientists On Long-Term Growth

CorD Recommends

Belgrade Science Festival to Inspire Innovation and Curiosity

The Science Festival, the region’s largest event...

Chinese Rover Finds New Evidence of Ancient Ocean in Northern Mars

Scientists studying data from China’s Zhurong rover...

Satellite Images Show Pakistan’s Smog Visible from Space

NASA satellite images reveal that smog in...

Chinese Astronauts Bring 34.6 Kilograms of Space Samples to Earth

Three Chinese astronauts have returned to Earth...

Neoplanta Celebrates New Life with Generous Gesture

In a touching display of community spirit, Neoplanta, a renowned food company based in Novi Sad, once again marked...

The Hermitage Days are Being Held Again in Belgrade in 2025

The Hermitage Days in Serbia represent a unique international cultural project that will take place from February 19 to...

AgroBelgrade 2025 – A Hub for Innovation and Trade in Agriculture and Horticulture

Over 500 exhibitors will converge at the three-day AgroBelgrade 2025, bringing together the best of Eastern Europe’s fruit, vegetable,...

Europe’s Stark Divide in Land Prices and Rentals

A sharp contrast in land prices across Europe reveals a growing divide in agricultural affordability, with Malta leading the...

Increase In the Number of Transactions in the Austrian M&A market

The Austrian mergers and acquisitions (M&A) market experienced an increase in the number of transactions, but the total value...

Most economic forecasters have largely shrugged off recent advances in artificial intelligence (for example, the quantum leap demonstrated by DeepMind’s self-learning chess program last December), seeing little impact on longer-term trend growth. Such pessimism is surely one of the reasons why real (inflation-adjusted) interest rates remain extremely low, even if the bellwether US ten-year bond rate has ticked up half a percentage point in the last few months.

If supply-side pessimism is appropriate, the recent massive tax and spending packages in the United States will likely do much more to raise inflation than to boost investment.

There are plenty of reasons to object to recent US fiscal policy, even if lowering the corporate-tax rate made sense (albeit not by the amount enacted). Above all, we live in an era of rising inequality and falling income shares for labour relative to capital. Governments need to do more, not less, to redistribute income and wealth.

It is hard to know what US President Donald Trump is thinking when he boasts that his policies will deliver up to 6% growth (unless he is talking about prices, not output!). But if inflationary pressures do indeed materialize, current growth might last significantly longer than forecasters and markets believe.

In any case, the focus of economists’ pessimism is long-term growth. Their stance is underpinned by the belief that advanced economies cannot hope to repeat the dynamism that the US enjoyed from 1995-2005 (and other advanced economies a bit later), much less the salad days of the 1950s and 1960s.

But the doubters ought to consider the fact that many scientists, across many disciplines, see things differently. Young researchers, in particular, believe that advances in basic knowledge are coming as fast as ever, even if practical applications are taking a long time to develop.

Indeed, a small but influential cult touts the Hungarian-American mathematician John von Neumann’s “singularity” theory.

Someday, thinking machines will become so sophisticated that they will be able to invent other machines without any human intervention, and suddenly technology will advance exponentially.

If so, perhaps we should be far more worried about the ethical and social implications of material growth that is faster than humans can spiritually absorb. The angst over AI mostly focuses on inequality and the future of work. But as science fiction writers have long warned us, the potential threats arising from the birth of silicon-based “life” forms are truly frightening.

It is hard to know who is right: neither economists nor scientists have a great track record when it comes to making long-term predictions. But right now, and leaving aside the possibility of an existential battle between man and machine, it seems quite plausible to expect a significant pickup in productivity growth over the next five years.

Consider that the main components of economic growth are increases in the labour force, increases in investment (both public and private), and “productivity,” namely the output than can be produced with a given amount of inputs, thanks to new ideas. Over the past 10-15 years, all three have been dismally low in the advanced economies.

Labour force growth has slowed sharply, owing to declining birth rates, with immigration failing to compensate even in pre-Trump America. The influx of women into the labour force played a major role in boosting growth in the latter part of the twentieth century. But now that has largely played out, although governments could do more to support female labour force participation and pay equity.

Similarly, global investment has collapsed since the 2008 financial crisis (though not in China), lowering potential growth. And measured productivity growth has declined everywhere, falling roughly by half in the US since the tech boom of the mid-1990s. No wonder global real interest rates are so low, with high post-crisis savings chasing a smaller supply of investment opportunities.

Still, the best bet is that AI and other new technologies will eventually come to have a much larger impact on growth than they have up to now. It is well known that it can take a very long time for businesses to reimagine productive processes to exploit new technologies: railroads and electricity are two leading examples. The pickup in global growth is likely to be a catalyst for change, creating incentives for firms to invest and introduce new technologies, some of which will substitute for labour, offsetting the slowdown in the growth of the workforce.

With the after-effects of the financial crisis fading, and AI perhaps starting to gain traction, trend US output growth can easily stay strong for the next several years (though, of course, a recession is also possible). The likely corresponding rise in real global interest rates will be tricky for central bankers to navigate. In the best case, they will be able to “ride the wave,” as Alan Greenspan famously did in the 1990s, though more inflation is likely this time.

The bottom line is that neither policymakers nor markets should be betting on the slow growth of the past decade carrying over to the next. But that might not be entirely welcome news. If the scientists are right, we may come to regret the growth we get.

Kenneth Rogoff is Professor of Economics and Public Policy at Harvard University and recipient of the 2011 Deutsche Bank Prize in Financial Economics

Related Articles

Slovakia Offers to Host Peace Talks Between Russia and Ukraine

Slovakia has confirmed its readiness to host peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine, according to government officials. Russian President Vladimir Putin has expressed that Slovakia...

Donald Trump Named TIME’s Person of the Year for the Second Time

For 97 years, TIME magazine editors have selected the Person of the Year—an individual who, for better or worse, has most influenced the world...

Coffee Prices in New York Hit 27-Year High

According to a Bloomberg market report, coffee futures in New York have surged to their highest level since 1997, driven by mounting concerns over...

Global Cryptocurrency Market Value Surpasses $3 Trillion

The value of the global cryptocurrency market has exceeded $3 trillion as Donald Trump's election as U.S. President fueled speculation that favorable U.S. regulations...

Trump Secures Historic Return to the White House in Stunning Upset

In a dramatic electoral comeback, Republican Donald Trump has seized victory over Democratic contender Kamala Harris in the U.S. presidential race, reclaiming the White...

Uncovering a Lost Chopin Waltz

A previously unknown waltz by Frédéric Chopin, written nearly 200 years ago, has been discovered in the vaults of New York’s Morgan Library and...

89 Serbian Scientists Ranked Among World’s Most Influential Researchers

A total of 89 Serbian scientists have been ranked among the world’s 217,097 most influential researchers, according to the latest list published by Stanford...

Analysts Predict Coffee Prices Could Reach Unimaginable Levels in the Future

Paying £5, or €5.9 for a cup of coffee in London, or $7 in New York, seems hard to imagine from today's perspective, but...